Introducing Peacherryblue: Peach, Cherry & Blueberry Pies in Three Cake Layers

When I learned one of my Thanksgiving guests was going to attempt a turducken (a chicken in a duck in a turkey), naturally I thought I needed to have a complement on the dessert side.

Peachcherryblue a/k/a Triple Threat.

The problem: Cherpumple recipes (cherry, pumpkin, apple pie/layer cake) with fondant icing or buttercream frosting seemed absolutely gross to me. I just couldn’t see investing the time and energy into a layer cake that I wouldn’t eat.

So after several days thinking through which ingredients and cake pairings could work, I came up with what turned out to be a pretty fantastic fruity layer cake.

First layer was a little over full.

I love cherry and blueberry together. And I think peach and blueberry are a pretty tasty pairing. So picking the fruit was easy.

For the cakes, I went with complementary flavors: For cherry, I chose French vanilla; for blueberry, the choice (thanks to a co-worker) was lemon; and for peach, the inspired choice (and because Betty Crocker makes it available), was butter pecan.

Pretty messy without a springform pan.

The final piece of the pie was the frosting. I couldn’t imagine a heavy, butter-based frosting. But I understand why people choose thick, dense frosting… because you need something to cover up flubs or bind the layers together.

Around midnight, before I had to be up to prep for the big meal, I found this sour cream topping, a fluffy frosting that did a fairly decent job covering mistakes, but wasn’t heavy tasting or too sweet.

Plastic wrap to bind it.

It’s hard to explain, but the flavors just worked.

Even the doubters (me included) had to admit it was a tasty combination.

So next time you’re looking for a challenging dessert to wow your guests, try what my father dubbed Peacherryblue. You won’t be disappointed.

More than halfway through, the structure started to fail.

Then total collapse. Still delicious.

Published by Virtual Farmgirl

Virtual Farmgirl is a communications professional with a dream of one day becoming a real farmgirl.

Leave a comment